Tag: suheil laher

Mutawatir and Ahad Hadiths

Authority of Ahad and Mutawatir Hadith

A mutawatir narration is one which is:

narrated by a multitude of narrators
their numbers being such that experience / common sense rules out the possibility of their all having colluded to lie, or of their all having made the same mistake or fabrication by coincidence
with such numbers being present in each generation (level) of the chain of narration
the chain ending with something which was directly sensed (e.g. seen, heard) by the initial narrator (as opposed to something s/he concluded or hypothesized).
[see: Sharh Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikr, by `Ali al-Qari, (being a commentary on Hafiz Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalani’s summary text and commentary), pp. 161 ff.]

We encounter this type of narration often in the mundane aspects of our lives. It is by such narrations that we have come to know about distant lands which we have never visited, and similarly about events and people in the past, yet because of the certainty conveyed by these narrations, we do not doubt the existence of these entities. For example, we know about the tyranny of certain world leaders of our day, the poverty of Haiti, and the fact that there is a US-led war going on in `Iraq, because the numerous, abundant reports we have heard about these things have served to corroborate one another to the extent that we have become convinced without doubt that these are incontrovertible facts. Continue reading “Mutawatir and Ahad Hadiths”

Ibn Hazm on Authority of the Sunnah

The Authority of the Sunnah

selections from

Al-Ihkam fi Usul al-Ahkam

vol I, pp. 96-108, Dar al-Afaq al-Jadidah, Beirut, 2nd ed., 1983/1402.

by Imam `Ali Ibn Hazm (d. 456 H)

“Since we have clarified [in the previous section] that the Qur’an is the source of reference for laws, we looked into it, and found therein the obligation of obedience to what the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) has ordered us, and we found [Allah] the Mighty, the Majestic therein describing His messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), [translated], “He does not speak of his own desire. It is only an inspiration with which he is inspired.” Q[53:3-4] Thus, it is proved for us thereby that inspiration from Allah, the Mighty the Majestic, to His Messenger, can be divided into two categories: one of them [being] recited inspiration compiled in a miraculous form, which is the Qur’an, and the second [being] narrated inspiration, neither compiled [into a single book] nor of miraculous composition, and that is the narrations which have come from the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), his being the explainer on behalf of Allah, the Mighty the Majestic. Allah, the Exalted, says, [translated], “…in order that you may explain to people what has been sent down to them.” Q[16:44] We found [Allah] the Exalted obligating obedience to this second category as He obliged obedience to the first category, without any difference, for [Allah] the Exalted, has said, [translated], “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger.” Q[5:92 and others] Continue reading “Ibn Hazm on Authority of the Sunnah”

On the Methodology of Acquiring Knowledge

Praise be to Allah, the Mighty, the Exalted, and blessings and peace be upon His chosen messenger.
The Qur’anic and hadith texts on the virtues and excellences of knowledge are numerous, and need not be listed here, for they are not the subject of disagreement.  Those who so desire may peruse them in the appropriate references.  What is, however, sometimes overlooked, is that knowledge is taken first and foremost from the scholars; books alone are not sufficient to make a person a scholar.  The scholars say, “Knowledge may not be taken from a SuHufi (‘journalist – one who studied only from books) nor the Qur’an from a muSHafi (one who learned to recite the Qur’an on his own, without a teacher).”

1. Evidence from the Qur’an and Sunnah

Allah sent the Qur’an – a book – with a Messenger – a teacher, to explain its contents.
(“And We have sent down to you the Reminder in order that you might explain to people what has been sent down to them.”) [Qur’an]
The story of the Sahabi who misinterpreted the verse about the black and white threads of dawn is well known.  And, according to a narration in Sunan Ibn Majah, the Prophet criticized those Companions who, based on the outward meaning of the Qur’an, gave the fatal fatwa that tayammum is not permissible for one who has water, even if he fears the water will harm him.  It is reported that he said, “Could they not have asked, since they did not know? The only remedy for incompetence is asking.” Continue reading “On the Methodology of Acquiring Knowledge”

2 – Prayer

RITUAL PRAYER (SALAH)

(According to the Qur’an and Sunnah,
as extracted and inferred by scholars of the Hanafi school.)
From “Mukhtasar al-Quduri“, a matn of Hanafi fiqh

  1. Times for Salah
    • Times of Salah
    • Preferred Times
    • Disliked and Prohibited Times
  2. Adhan
    • Its form
    • Its sunnahs
  3. The Constituents and Manner of Performing the Salah
    • Its Pre-Requisistes
    • Its Rudiments
    • Its Obligations
    • Description of the Salah
    • Disliked Actions in Salah
    • Disruptors and Nullifiers of the Salah
    • Prostrations of Inattentiveness
    • Prostration of Recitation
  4. Group Prayer

4b – Prophet Muhammad

“Whoever saw him for the first time was awed by him, and whoever mingled with him and got to know him loved him.” Thus was the Prophet Muhammad described by one of his close companions. Even today, some 1,400 years later, one who comes to know of the Prophet cannot fail to be impressed by this man who, from humble beginnings and in the face of persecution, brought about such a profound change in the world. Today, over a billion people, spanning scores of nationalities, colors and languages, consider themselves followers of his religion, and uphold the system of spiritual devotion and morals taught by him. All this is the fruit of the simple message that was the core of his preaching, “There is no god but God.” Surely, everyone ought to be acquainted with his life and teachings.

Birth and Early Youth

Allah’s final prophet and messenger, Muhammad, was born in the sixth century after Christ (ca. 570 C.E.) in the Arabian city of Makkah, among the Arab tribe of Quraysh. The Arabs as a whole trace their bloodline to Abraham’s son Ishmael. Quraysh was an especially prestigious tribe, for they were in charge of the holy sanctuary of the Ka`bah, which had been built by Abraham and Ishmael. However, the pure monotheism of Abraham had by now degenerated into idolatry. People from all over Arabia would still make pilgrimage to the Ka`bah, but for idolatrous worship.

Muhammad’s father, `Abdullah, had died before he was born, and his mother, Aaminah, died when he was just six years old. His grandfather, `Abdul-Muttalib took care of him for the next two years. When `Abdul-Muttalib, too, died, the eight-year old Muhammad passed into the custody of his paternal uncle, Abu Talib. He thus grew up as an orphan. The Makkan society was not particularly literate, and he did not receive an education. In his early youth, he worked as a shepherd, and later became an employee of a prosperous trader-woman named Khadijah. The young Muhammad came to earn a reputation for honesty and trustworthiness, and was nicknamed Al-Amin (The Trustworthy) by his people. The wealthy Khadijah was so impressed by him that she asked to marry him. He accepted, although she was 40 years old and so 15 years his senior. The marriage lasted twenty-five years, until Khadijah’s death, and he did not marry any other women during this time.

Preaching

Muhammad shunned his people’s idolatry, and eventually started taking solitary spiritual retreats in the mountains around Makkah. It was during one such retreat, at the age of 40, that the Angel Gabriel came to him with the first revelation from God,

“Recite in the name of your Lord who created.
Created man from a clinging substance.
Recite, and your Lord is the most Generous.
Who taught by the pen.
Taught man that which he knew not.” [Qur’an, 96:1-5]

His mission was to teach pure monotheism: the worship of God alone, which had been the faith of all prophets. For thirteen years, he exhorted his people to submit to their Creator and shun false worship, to be morally upright and to realize that human beings face an existence after death and will there be judged by God for their earthly lives. This simple message met stiff and even harsh resistance from many in Quraysh, as people’s stubbornness, vested interests and smugness prevented them from responding thoughtfully. The Prophet’s character and truthfulness and character were not doubted, even by his fiercest opponents. [See: Qur’an, 6:33] At the height of the persecution, the people of Makkah would still leave valuable items with him for safekeeping.

Refuge in Madinah

Eventually, he along with those who had believed in him, were driven out of Makkah, and took refuge in the city of Madinah some 300 miles north. The people of Madinah were both more hospitable and more responsive, and ten years later, the religion had gained a sizeable following there. Islam established itself as a social polity, despite continued military activity against it by the idolators of Quraysh. It was also during this stage that most of the religious regulations (such as fasting, charity and family law) were revealed. Islam became so firmly established that the Prophet Muhammad was eventually able to return triumphantly to Makkah without having to fight. His former persecutors were at his mercy, and retribution could easily have been inflicted on them for the past. The Prophet Muhammad, however, declared a general amnesty, in emulation of Prophet Joseph [Qur’an, 12:92]. Only a few criminals were excluded, and even most of these were later forgiven.

The Call Spreads

Within a few years, all of Arabia became Muslim, with people entering the religion in droves. [Qur’an, 110:2] The Prophet, however, had been sent as a mercy to all of humankind [Qur’an, 21:107], not only for his people the Arabs. He now began sending letters to rulers and emperors of other lands, including those of Rome, Persia and Abyssinia. Shortly before his death, and in a culmination of his mission, he performed the pilgrimage rites, during which he addressed the gathering of over 100,000 pilgrims, reminding them of the basic Islamic teachings, and of each individual’s accountability before God.

The Man and His Character

Prophet Muhammad was a humble man who strictly prohibited his followers from bowing to him, worshipping him or otherwise exaggerating his status to anything more than a human messenger of God. [Bukhari, Muslim] His dwellings, food and bedding were of the simplest sort. [Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi] He would repair his own clothes, milk his sheep, and serve his family. [Tirmidhi, Mishkat] He epitomized mercy, in his concern for both his followers and his opponents, and on several occasions even forgave people who had tried to kill him. [Bukhari, Muslim] He was generous, fasted often, and would regularly stand in prayer for long hours at night, to the extent that his feet would become swollen. [Bukhari, Muslim] Even at the peak of his success, he continued to live a simple and pious life. When he died, some of his property was being held by a Jew as collateral for a loan the Prophet had taken from him. [Bukhari]

Finality of Prophethood

It is clear from the Qur’an that Prophet Muhammad is the last prophet. He is described as

“the Seal of the Prophets,” [Qur’an, 33:40] and as having been sent to all people [Qur’an, 6:19, 25:1, 21:157, 61:9]. The religion is described as having been perfected and completed [Qur’an, 5:3], and as meant to become preponderate over all other religions. [Qur’an, 9:33, 3:85]. The scripture’s preservation has been promised by God [Qur’an, 15:9, 41:42]. There is no place or function for a new prophet.

Turning to the hadith, the concept of finality of prophethood becomes still clearer. The hadiths on this topic are so numerous and conclusive that anyone denying them falls outside the pale of Islam. Among these hadiths are the following:

“My likeness, with regard to the prophets, is that of a man who built a house, and then perfected it and beautified it, except for the place of a brick, so that whoever used to enter [the house] and look at it said, ‘How fine it is, except the position of this brick!’  So, I am the position of the brick; the prophets – blessings and peace be upon them – were brought to an end by me.”  [Narrated by Bukhari and Muslim]

When the Prophet was departing on the military expedition of Tabuk, he appointed `Ali to stay behind to oversee Madinah. When `Ali expressed his disappointment as staying back with the weak and handicapped, the Prophet told him,

“Are you not satisfied that you are to me as Aaron was to Moses, except that there is no prophethood after me?” [Narrated by Bukhari and others. This hadith itself has been narrated through more than twenty chains of transmission.]

“The Children of Israel were ruled by prophets. Whenever a prophet died, another prophet took his place. There is no prophet after me, but there will be Caliphs….” [Narrated by Bukhari, Muslim]

In addition, we note that the Companions were in agreement that Musaylimah, Sajah and other claimants to prophethood that emerged in that period were to be treated as non-Muslims.

From a rational perspective, it is also conceivable that the finality of prophethood reflects a higher stage in the progressive intellectual development of the human race. A young boy might be given a book by his teacher, only to lose it or tear it up before long, because he does not know any better. Once he has matured sufficiently, however, he will realize the value of the book, and will take care of it, so that he will not need to be given another.

The earlier prophetic messages were typically sent to a single people, whereas the final message is universal, for all peoples up to the Day of Judgment.

Say, ‘O mankind! I am the messenger of Allah to you all.” [Qur’an, 7:158]

The advances in global communications can help us understand the need for a universal prophet, and his being the last necessarily implies that Allah guarantees preservation of the final scripture. It is not acceptable to reject the Qur’an on the claim of sticking to the book/law of a previous prophet.  Allah took a covenant from every prophet such that if he were to encounter Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), he would believe in him and follow him.  [Qur’an, 3:81] The Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) said, “There is no Jew, nor any Christian, who hears about me, and then does not believe in me and that which I have brought, except that Allah must enter him into the Fire.” [Narrated by Muslim]  He is also reported to have said, “If Moses were to descend, and you were to follow him and leave me, you would surely have strayed from the proper path”  [Narrated by Ahmad and others] The other prophets were all stars of divine guidance, and their books were sent by God for this purpose, but proving the accurate preservation of their original teachings is difficult today. Furthermore, it is not permissible to neglect the final star that has risen on the horizon. True faith requires accepting and believing in the entire constellation of prophets, according the appropriate place to each.

4a – The Messengers

Prelude: Human Messengers

Allah, in His wisdom and mercy, sent us messengers to direct us to what is beneficial.  These messengers were men at various times and in various communities whom Allah inspired with guidance for their people.  It is a blessing that they were human beings, like us, such that people could relate to them and interact with them. If the prophets and messengers had instead been angels (see: Qur’an, 6:9, 17:95), the same benefit could not have been accomplished.

“Certainly did Allah confer [great] favor upon the believers when He sent among them a Messenger from themselves, reciting to them His verses and purifying them and teaching them the Book and wisdom, although they had been before in manifest error.” [Qur’an, 3:164]

Messengers direct us to what is beneficial, remind us, and provide a basis for regulating public life. They convey and explain, guide and warn, and typically also cultivate and lead a society. (Q[4:165]) One who wishes to draw nearer to Allah should therefore follow the prophets and those who emulate their way.  In general, all the messengers are examples for us to follow[1]:

“They (the prophets) are those whom Allah has guided, so follow their guidance.” [Qur’an, 6:91] Continue reading “4a – The Messengers”

5f – Heaven and Hell

Heaven and Hell

Heaven and Hell have both been created and are currently in existence, as evidenced by verses of the Qur’an.

“It (Heaven) has been prepared for the pious.” [Qur’an, 3:133]

“Guard yourselves against the fire which has been prepared for the disbelievers.”  [Qur’an, 3:131]

Heaven

There are different levels in Heaven.

“And for each, there are ranks based on what they did.”  [Qur’an, 6:132]

“Those who believe, and whose offspring follow them in faith, We shall unite their offspring with them, and We shall not cause decrease the reward of their deeds at all.” [Qur’an, 52:21]  Ibn `Abbas said, “Allah will elevate the offspring of the believer, even if they were beneath him in deeds, in order that his eye might delight in them.” [Narrated by Tabari and Bazzar] Continue reading “5f – Heaven and Hell”

5e – Judgment

JUDGEMENT

The process of judgement on the Last Day can be conveniently discussed under four subheadings, corresponding to different aspects of the judgment:

1. Presentation of the Deeds (`Ard): each person’s deeds are presented before Allah, and thus they are exposed to their records, and to their Lord. This stage may therefore also be called the Exposing.

2. Questioning (Su’al): people are questioned about their deeds

3. Accounting or Reckoning (Hisab): people are held accountable, or brought to account, for their wrongs.

4. Judgement (Qada’) : judgement is given; the person comes to know whether he is destined to Heaven or to Hell. Continue reading “5e – Judgment”

5d – The Resurrection Plain

Creatures of the Resurrection Plain

Mankind and jinn will be gathered there in their entirety, including even the rebellious devils.

“Then, by your Lord!  We shall surely gather them, and the devils, and then We shall bring them around Hell on their knees.” [Qur’an, 19:68.  See also 6:128]  Also, “the days will be gathered in their forms.” [Tabarani] The earth shall be gathered there.  “On that day, [the earth] shall relate its news, because your Lord shall have inspired it.” [Qur’an, 99:4-5]  On the authority of Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be well pleased with him) : The Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) recited these verses, then asked, “Do you know what its news is?”  The Companions replied, “Allah and His Messenger know best.” He said, “Its news is that it testifies over every male and female concerning that which he/she did on its surface; that it says, ‘He did such-and-such on such-and-such day.  That is its news.” [Ahmad, Tirmidhi, Nasa’i]  Animals will also be resurrected.  “There is no animal upon the earth, nor any bird which flies with its two wings, except that they are nations like you.  We have not neglected anything in the Record.  Then, to their Lord shall they be gathered.” [Qur’an, 6:38]  `Abdur-Razzaq has reported that Abu Hurayrah said that Allah will judge between the animals, and then after they have been given their justice, they will be turned to dust.  At this point, the disbeliever will wish that he, too, would have been turned to dust.  [See: Qur’an, 78:40.] Continue reading “5d – The Resurrection Plain”

5c – Resurrection

After the intermediate realm of forty years, Allah will again command the angel Israfil to blow the Horn.

” . . . then [the Horn] will be blown another time, and behold! they shall be standing, looking.” [Qur;an, 39:68]

Allah will cause a special rain, called “The Water of Life”, to fall, and will thereby cause the bodies to grow from `ajb al-dhanab (a small bone at the end of the spine), in the same way as plants grow.

It is essential to believe in the bodily resurrection.  Just as both the body and soul participated in either obeying or disobeying Allah in this world, so it is only fitting that they should both receive the appropriate recompense of punishment and/or reward. A bodily resurrection is not rationally inconceivable, and furthermore, the texts of the Qur’an and authentic ahadith are quite explicit in their mention of physical pleasures and punishments in the Hereafter, such that there is no room left for doubt.  It was only some deviant individuals and groups, who, under the influence of the corrupt ideas of people of other religions and of the pagan philosophers, started to deny this fact, claiming that the Hereafter is purely spiritual, or that Heaven and Hell are mere states of mind which are consequential upon a person’s worldly conduct.  To persist upon such beliefs after receiving the message of the Qur’an is unacceptable, for it displays an obstinacy in accepting that which Allah has conveyed to us. Such beliefs might then be the fruits of baseless imaginings and Satanic whisperings that afflict those who are not content with clearly-stated, obvious truths.  Imam Ghazzali pronounced a verdict of disbelief on the philosphers on three counts : their claim that the universe is eternal, their denial of the bodily resurrection, and their denial that Allah knows the minute details of things. Continue reading “5c – Resurrection”